Theme: Billy Joel
Mentor: P. Diddy
Special Guest: Tommy Hilfiger
No matter what, the remaining singers are going on tour.
1. Deandre: "Only The Good Die Young" (1977)
2. Erika: "New York State of Mind" ('76)
3. Joshua: "She's Got a Way" ('82)
4. Skylar: "Shameless" ('91)
5. Elise: "Vienna" ('77)
6. Phillip: "Movin' Out (Anthony's Song)" ('77)
7. Hollie: "Honesty" ('79)
8. Heejun: "My Life" ('78)
9. Jessica: "Everybody Has a Dream" ('77)
10. Colton: "Piano Man" ('73)